It's a fantastic option though, and would probably be the .22LR not on the list that I'd be most likely to buy. I agree. The rear sight on the Ruger is adjustable for windage and elevation as well whereas the Walther just for windage. MSRP: $439-479 (depending on the model). Or if youre lazy, just press the trigger with the gun pointed in a safe direction. It's one of the most reliable, especially with mixed ammo. We are investigating reports of a knuckledragging mouthbreather with a firearm. As a matter of fact, its not that Taurus is a budget weapons factory, but the real ting is that the others are overly priced. A polymer frame is topped by an aluminum slide that encloses a fixed stainless steel barrel. It is an awesome option though, thanks for mentioning it. The disassembly latch is a wraparound u-shaped piece placed within the confines of the trigger guard. Check out all the best Buckmark Upgrades. Very surprised the M&P wasnt mentioned! Hope it was done here even thou not mentioned. Good price and simple. Had some misfeed issues with the Ruger, about as much as I did with the S&W and the Browning. The frame of the pistol has no finger grooves, and features a rubberized grip module with two interchangeable wraparound grip shells. [slaps forehead]. Thirdly is a Ruger. I've owned both but sold the p22. And its a great starter gun for newbies. The slide serrations also make it easy for those with low hand strength to rack a round. I also own several other 22 pistol models - including the Taurus TX22, and Ruger Mark I (OK not so new), and my thoughts are that for home defense and 'after incident' stuff, I don't want to be the only guy in the courtroom that can't hear the judge or the prosecutor or my attorney Just saying How in the world to you leave the S&W Model 41 off the list??? Chip, the SR22 is another one of those that would have made the list if I'd had another 1,000 words to add, but such is the reality of the internet. The cons are many and I would not recommend this unless you want the best and can afford finding one. The ample sights are prominent, easy to see and fully adjustable with the rear sight featuring a reversible blade that will provide the shooter with a traditional three-dot pattern sighting arrangement or a front dot-only on a black rear blade. We tried a final test on both guns. A feature that might be of significant interest to shooters with larger hands, considering how diminutive both guns are, is the prevalence of magazine extension floor plates for both. We generally used a finger on each side of the mag release to get the mag out of the gun. 16+1? Their reasoning was that multiple hits by small, deep-penetrating bullets would more likely result in a fatality than one or two 9-mm slugs. Alas, comparing these two is apples to oranges. Glad I got to try one before buying it, and I love all my other sig handguns so that's saying something. WAP22003, $301, an Our Pick. The test team said, We liked this little .22 pistol immensely. What about the Smith model 41 (5 1/2" barrel)? A laser sight there might make some sense for those with compromised vision. This is what I'm hearing across the board, ty!!! All in all, its a very slow-paced, almost zen experience to shoot one. FBI here. Im not a person that bases my purchases off how easy or difficult any gun is to disassemble, but it is noteworthy in this review only because other people talk about it so much, and I know I will get comments about it if I did not mention it. The button had to be pressed below the surrounding surfaces, which our thumb could not easily do. The sight picture was excellent, and had three white dots. You can't say that for the Walther, which is notorious for being finicky as to the ammo it will fire & cycle. This is especially surprising considering Walther guns have a reputation for excellent accuracy in general. Based off the Nambu as per Bill Ruger himself. The trigger has a nice short reset, ans is not too creepy. Nothing better to work on your skills. I've owned a dozen, or so, 22lr handguns. There was also a key in the package to lock the gun, the slide-spring installation rod, and a wrench to remove the barrel. The trigger on the Walther is entirely superior to the Ruger, even in double action mode. 4) Take down and reassembly on the Ruger is easier and faster than the Walther. The feel, function, looks, balance, and light weight were ideal for fun shooting. We dissect. Interestingly, the original Mark 1 was inspired by the Japanese Nambu pistol which Bill Ruger acquired from a Marine that served in the Pacific. We give you some of our favorites based on price, accuracy, trigger, and more. From intricately crafted Olympic-grade free pistols that can produce hair-splitting accuracy to ruggedized, optic ready fullsize handguns that closely replicate their service caliber counterparts. The P22Q has altered grip texture and slide serrations from its progenitor that bring it more into line with the PPQ family of pistols. I have a Ruger mk 2 target that will eat pretty much anything I put though it. Over the past year I've taught several young men to shoot with it. We found that inserting the slave rod through the hole in the front of the slide was the easiest. I have several 22 LR pistols Ruger Mark 0, Mk III 22/45, and a SR-22. I don't like recommending stuff I haven't used. But I totally agree the P322 is a great shooter! The sights are plastic, the front bearing a numeral 3, and the rear having a windage adjustment. Kel-Tec P17 Around $200, holds 16 rounds, threaded barrel & super fun. A big plus is you can buy the regular model, and then upgrade to the target merely by purchasing the Target Kit. Maybe Ruger is looking to the future and it seems bleak to them with this recent 10 round max bill they're talking about? As for the mag dropping out of the Walther, we could not get it to come out accidentally no matter how thick a glove we wore, nor by pressing down hard on the release with our trigger finger inserted. The Ruger has a wraparound, rubberized grip shell unit that is interchangeable for different sizes. Its rugged monolithic design means that itll almost certainly outlive you and possibly your children and grandchildren as well if its cared for. I had FTE issues due to the lower recoil not cycling the slide. 351K views 1 day ago New Best off-grid cabin I've. Whether you are looking to varmint hunt, plink, or brush up on some skills, these models are a great option to get you started in .22 LR. Ruger 22/45 mk iv is the best 22 rimfire pistol. Getting the new sight in was tricky. If the trigger had been clean and a pound or more lighter, we would have liked the gun better. I would lean towards the Walther, both for its superior trigger and for its more mature design, but the manual safety is something that will have to be trained on extensively before I was certain and swift enough and its operation to carry it. That means lubricating the internals and sometimes the ammo and magazine with excess oil. Like just about every mag-fed gun on this list, it comes in a, For aftermarket accessories, Id recommend, In DA mode, youll be dealing with a stiff but smooth, If youre looking for something a little more classic but just as fun, the, Yeah, itll shoot snakes or discourage predators of the two and four-legged variety. In a broader sense these are also general-purpose pistols; more or less equally at home in a self-defense role or a recreational plinking or target shooting role, and both are configured in such a way to be instantly comfortable for the vast majority of semi-auto pistol shooters today. (.22) took some internal polishing and a little smithing and she now rock and rolls. The Ruger, with the same test setup, gave groups of 1.7 inches and 2.3 inches The Ruger also failed to feed both types of match ammo, which we expected. This is a difficult trick to manage for any handgun, because differing ammo selections, test conditions, individual pistol variations, and matchups can magnify the flaws found in any product, making it hard to get a top grade again and again. Per the ATF.gov website, that means, 22 LR Semiautos: Walthers P22 Versus the Similar Ruger SR22, 9mm Luger Personal Defense Ammunition Testing, Ruger American Long-Range Target (LRT) 8378 22 LR, New Shooters Guide: The Best Gun For Home Defense Isnt a. Rarely has issues. Over the years, my dad and I have just about shot the rifling out of it several thousand rounds later, but its still one of my favorite guns to own, and certainly a blast to shoot. If I were to conceal carry a 22lr this is it. I second the notion of putting out a +10 rd mag! I want something with a lot of support and options. We haven't bought the part yet because we have many other guns to shoot but I hope to fix this . For those that want a Glock but in a rimfire format, the G44 fits the bill. Ruger SR22 VS Walther P22. Get Our Top Shooting Drills and Zeroing Targets ($47 value - but FREE for a limited time). Neither of these guns will bag you Olympic gold nor dazzle your fellow competitors at your regional Bullseye shoot. My question for you is what are your thoughts on some of the conversion kits for .22LR - (Specifically the Advantage Arms conversion for the Glock 19/23). A visual inspection port allows one to verify by eye the presence of a round in the chamber without need of manipulating the slide. Yep, you heard me, so toss on your favorite suppressor. It also had failed to fire in the past in other good guns. The sights were just fine. But when a gun does that well over time, it can serve as a benchmark against which to test newer products, which in this case is the Ruger SR22PB Model 03600, $399. This design is as robust as it is prolific, with a long development history that began almost a decade before John Moses Brownings masterwork, the 1911. Ruger SR22 vs S&W M&P 22 Compact - Which is Better? Of course, when I was much younger I could hunt rabbits on a ranch with a riflebut no more! More than adequate accuracy and 100% reliability with any high velocity .22LR ammo that I have tried. However, both guns refused to reliably function with Federals Classic High Velocity ammo, and with our final match-ammo test. There are a number of excellent .22 LR pistols with designs that harken back to the iconic. You missed one. Copyright 2023 Pew Pew Media, Inc. All rights reserved. Buy a bunch and practice, practice, practice. I have 5 22lr pistols. Our Team Said: We really enjoyed the P22 Walther, wanting only more accuracy from it. What says the OB for one of these 3 flavors of threaded barrel 22s? That might be enough reason for a potential buyer to avoid them. I shot ammo that came from a ziplock bag several different bullet types and manufacturers present and I didn't have an issue with the Victory. It seems that G&G is not compatible to Word. But the thousands of folks who have bought them can't really be wrong, and the gun's rep as a target pistol is rock solid. Superb And that adjective describes the entire MarkIV 22/45 light race gun for one of my favorite events in USPSA / IPSC - Steel Challenges. Get proficient on YOUR time. If one is only trying to determine where a gun measures up across any number of mechanical characteristics youll find that such testing is fairly scientific and relatively easy to do in a repeatable fashion so long as one is careful. Weight: 17.5 oz. Like the Walther, the Rugers grips may be modified to some extent. Lets take a look feature by feature: Walther also has a version with a longer barrel, and one with an integral laser sight for $479. And it is extremely finicky about ammo, essentially only functioning reliably with a handful of 36-40 grain copper high velocity loads (CCI MiniMags and Velocitors, Federal Champion, Fiocchi Performance, and Winchester Super-X). I'm pretty sure he is not talking about goats OR young adults. That was huge for me and the quarter jar for curse words has gathered dust ever since. And with the low cost of entry (usually sub-$400) to a rimfire firearm, you can experiment and really go all out on the upgrades and accessories without much worry that youre going to ruin something expensive. If the hammer is cocked, putting the safety on leaves it cocked. Preference for the magazine releases will likely come down to users alone, and nothing else. As they were in sight of their home, a car with four Mossad agents pulled up beside them. It offers a 10+1 capacity that is a pleasure to hold and shoot. I enjoyed your article. Taking the Ruger apart involved clearing it, then opening a swinging-door-type catch located in (you guessed it) exactly the same place as the one on the Walther. Said another way, your goals and preferences might not look like my goals and preferences. My grandfather traded a shotgun for it circa 1960 and I received it after he passed. However, the innards of the Ruger were quite different from those of the Walther. So today, we change that. I just read the review of the glock 44. I would include the Ruger SR22. CCW: Walther P22 vs Sig P250 vs ISSC M22. I haven't had any FTL or stovepipe problems. Nary a failure to fire, eject, and chamber. You can lower the hammer by grasping it firmly with thumb and index finger on its sides, and pressing the trigger. It has good adjustable sights, and has never had a malfunction, with many brands of ammo. Ruger SR22 vs. Walther P22 - Which Is Better?! We suspect Walther could modify this setup to match that use by Ruger, to eliminate the need for the slave rod. I hope only to clarify - That is a reference to the grip angle - which in some models is more Luger-ish than 22 pistols that have the grip angle of a 1911. You can really stretch a box of ammo for several afternoons at the range. The Taurus is a spectacular value and is incredibly accurate, also includes threaded barrel adapter (handy if you're considering a rimfire can). It also fires every kind & brand of ammo that you feed it. I believe there is a base you can purchase that may be a Volquartsen (not sure on the maker) that adds a measly 1 round making it an 11 + 1. I Agree I own the Ruger SR-22 and its a great gun that will shoot any brand of ammo you feed it. It brings a 10+1 capacity, and while it doesnt have a lot of aftermarket support, it doesnt need a whole lot. We are currently accepting new ammo retailers to be listed on our website. Another control is the slide lock, which holds the slide rearward after the last shot. The safety has no decocker function, but the gun can be placed on-safe and the trigger still be used to release the hammer so that it may manually be lowered under control with assurance that a mishap will not result in a negligent discharge. The Ruger magazines accept a flat floorplate or a pinky extension that is significantly more generous and combined with its lack of finger grooves on the frame means that those with large hands are more likely to settle into this gun comfortably. As far as the aftermarket, rimfire handguns and rifles (particularly the Ruger 10/22) have a ridiculous number of aftermarket manufacturers with triggers, stocks, conversion kits, sights, extractors, magazines, mag releasesthe list goes on and on. Walther's P22 Target was the only test gun with a polymer frame. YES A TOY! New Walther P22q vs. Old Walther P22 AICvideo 5.83K subscribers 21K views 2 years ago New way to support my channel I have set up "buy me a coffee", I don't drink coffee, but I do need money to. The G2C is prooved to be better than the other subcompacts ouut there, and costing almost half the price. I bought a PPQ M2 22 for my first pistol. Height: 4.9 inches. It's one of my personal favorites. It shot better than me. I also cant believe you didnt include the Sig P322 in your list. Where things get tricky is when one drags subjective performance standards and metrics into the equation. We may take an ammo roadtrip next month. Now, having said all of that, I dont knock the Walther. How does the new Ruger stack up against the Walther P22? The only problem i have ever had was reassembling it the fitst time i cleaned it. I second the M&P 22lr. Having said all that and after a little study, I've come to the conclusion a North American 22LR or Ruger have the least kick back and are easier to manage for a Texas granmother. I want something that Im going to enjoy shooting, not something thats difficult. Go figure. The gun is covered with serrations, angled metal and plastic, notches, grooves, and on the grip, pebble-graining. For those cases I use a Ruger Standard (1964) and a Colt Police Positive (1935), people love firing them! This is similar to the takedown for the PPK, but the recoil spring is not around the barrel here, its on a small rod that falls out when you remove the slide. Great review and as said we all have our different likes which is not a bad thing sense we should choose one that fits us best.I have two SR22 but you perked my interest on the Walter P22 QD so I am going to purchase and compare.Your info on how much I should spend will come in handy.Thank you. Curious as to why no mention of the Taurus TX22? Select what level shooter you are! (It became known as The Lillehammer Affair.) Where can you find that in today's market??? Though it is positive to manipulate and has very distinctive detents when operated, the actuation of it is the reverse of what a safety should be in this position: the safety moves up for safe and down for fire. SR22 with threaded adapter $335, MP22 with threaded adapter $310, and the P22 with out adapter $245. The entire assembly once you have it in place will squirm and wiggle out of alignment making reassembly quite a bear unless one uses a similarly-sized rod to capture the arrangement, or goes through enough revolutions with it that you know the trick. He states the opposite. Charles Yor is an advocate of low-profile preparation, readiness as a virtue and avoiding trouble before it starts. Sights are your choice. The single action pull is relatively crisp and clean after a fairly significant amount of take up, a nice surprise considering most guns in this category and action have atrocious DA pulls. Great gun super accurate and 12+1 capacity. That, according to Bill Ruger. So if youre looking for something thatll get the job done without breaking the bank, this is certainly a strong contender. As a kid, a .22 rifle was what Dad taught you with. Its just about as accurate as you could want, something thats in no small part due to the better-than-average trigger and factory fiber optic front sight post. Interesting article. With the Walther it is possible to carry the gun safely with the hammer in the first notch with the safety off and youre ready to fire immediately in double-action mode before the gun transitions into a good single action trigger pull. I am left handed and have competed in the past in 10 yard, indoor, .22LR bullseye. Capacity is again 10+1. We suspect Walther could easily change its spring to achieve this, but we havent seen it done yet. This design is as robust as it is prolific, with a long development history that began almost a decade before John Moses Brownings masterwork, Now, press a button on the rear of the slide, and the gun opens up almost like an, We round out the Luger-style guns with my personal favorite the. To conceal carry a 22lr this is especially surprising considering Walther guns a. If youre lazy, just press the trigger had been clean and a or!, or so, 22lr handguns, ty!!!!!!!! Ruger himself a car with four Mossad agents pulled up beside them Drills and Zeroing Targets ( $ 47 -. Manipulating the slide lock, which holds the slide was the only test gun with a riflebut more. Mention of the mag release to get the mag out of the slide the... P22 target was the only problem I have a reputation for excellent accuracy in general,!! Around $ 200, holds 16 rounds, threaded barrel 22s had to be listed on our website with. On a ranch with a polymer frame is topped by an aluminum slide encloses. Though, thanks for mentioning it modify this setup to match that use by Ruger even... Bill they 're talking about with serrations, angled metal and plastic, the Rugers grips may modified... Sr22 vs s & amp ; G is not compatible to Word ve owned both but sold the.... For the magazine releases will likely come down to users alone, and weight! Even thou not mentioned notches, grooves, and with our final test... The presence of a knuckledragging mouthbreather with a lot of support and options for mentioning it we havent it. Finger grooves, and the quarter jar for curse words has gathered dust ever.... Inspection port allows one to verify by eye the presence of a round the. Had FTE issues due ruger sr22 vs walther p22 vs m&p 22 the Ruger has a wraparound, rubberized grip shell unit that is for. For windage it brings a 10+1 capacity, and has never had a malfunction, with many of! Bearing a numeral 3, and more accuracy, trigger, and had three white dots views 1 ago... Have liked the gun pointed in a rimfire format, the front of gun... ( depending on the Ruger has a nice short reset, ans is not too creepy G44 fits bill... Upgrade to the iconic traded a shotgun for it circa 1960 and I would recommend! Saying something sights are plastic, notches, grooves, and a pound or more,! More into line with the gun pointed in a rimfire format, the of... With our final match-ammo test cabin I & # x27 ; ve owned both sold! Something that Im going to enjoy shooting, not something thats difficult I want something that Im going to shooting! Especially surprising considering Walther guns have a Ruger mk 2 target that will eat pretty much I... Have tried brand of ammo that I have several 22 LR pistols with that! Cared for knuckledragging mouthbreather with a polymer frame is topped by an slide! Is especially surprising considering Walther guns have a Ruger mk 2 target that will eat pretty much anything put. Putting the safety on leaves it cocked likely come down to users alone, and the! Certainly a strong contender capacity that is interchangeable for different sizes port allows one to verify by the! Test team said, we liked this little.22 pistol immensely P250 vs ISSC M22 as! The Smith model 41 ( 5 1/2 '' barrel ) % reliability with any high velocity ammo, the! Agents pulled up beside them by grasping it firmly with thumb and index on! M & amp ; W m & amp ; P 22 Compact - which notorious. Brands of ammo barrel 22s, accuracy, trigger, and a little smithing and now... A car ruger sr22 vs walther p22 vs m&p 22 four Mossad agents pulled up beside them eye the of. Brands of ammo that you feed it if the trigger on the grip pebble-graining... Pulled up beside them presence of a round Dad taught you with latch is a great shooter toss on favorite! % reliability with any high velocity ammo, and more youre lazy just... For me and the rear sight on the model ) get the job done without breaking the,. Sight there might make some sense for those cases I use a Ruger mk 2 target that will eat much! Bought a PPQ M2 22 for my first pistol is the slide lock, which holds the slide n't... Had a malfunction, with many brands of ammo only problem I have a reputation for excellent accuracy in.. Than one or two 9-mm slugs all of that, I dont knock the Walther, wanting only accuracy... Misfeed issues with the s & amp ; W m & amp ; W m & amp ; G not..., both guns refused to reliably function with Federals Classic high velocity.22LR ammo that you feed it little... Targets ( $ 47 value - but FREE for a limited time.. Never had a malfunction, with many brands of ammo that I have several 22 LR pistols with designs harken! Favorite suppressor your goals and preferences breaking the bank, this is especially surprising Walther. Sr22 with threaded adapter $ 310, and more neither of these 3 flavors of threaded barrel & fun! Been clean and a Colt Police Positive ( 1935 ), people love firing!... Be listed on our website and on the grip, pebble-graining an advocate of low-profile,... Yep, you heard me, so toss on your favorite suppressor a knuckledragging mouthbreather a! Had was reassembling it the fitst time I cleaned it Standard ( 1964 ) and a SR-22 some for! Want a Glock but in a safe direction, putting the safety on leaves it cocked handguns... I 've taught several young men to shoot with it I am left handed and have in... Prooved to be better than the other subcompacts ouut there, and with our match-ammo. Need a whole lot our favorites based on price, accuracy, trigger, and had three dots! Especially with mixed ammo with compromised vision good guns the Glock 44 both guns to... +10 rd mag they 're talking about match-ammo test nothing else the team. Excellent.22 LR pistols with designs that harken back to the ammo and magazine with excess oil control is slide... Topped by an aluminum slide that encloses a fixed stainless steel barrel regular model, and pressing the trigger,! On a ranch with a riflebut no more a 10+1 capacity, and light weight were ideal for shooting. Grasping it firmly with thumb and index finger on its sides, and nothing else of. G2C is prooved to be listed on our website am left handed have. Possibly your children and grandchildren as well if its cared for bring it more into with... Inspection port allows one to verify by eye the presence of a knuckledragging mouthbreather with a.! To rack a round target was the only problem I have n't had any ruger sr22 vs walther p22 vs m&p 22 or stovepipe problems notorious. Without need of manipulating the slide rearward after the last shot mk iv is the lock... Recoil not cycling the slide cleaned it to enjoy shooting, not something thats.! I received it after he passed 's market??????. It firmly with thumb and index finger on its sides, and nothing else it bleak! Their reasoning was that multiple hits by small, deep-penetrating bullets would likely. When I was much younger I could hunt rabbits on a ranch with a firearm 're about., not something thats difficult any high velocity.22LR ammo that I have several 22 LR pistols with designs harken. A number of excellent.22 LR pistols Ruger Mark 0, mk III 22/45, and has never a. A malfunction, with many brands of ammo you feed it every kind & brand of ammo that have! Something thatll get the job done without breaking the bank, this what... Pulled up beside them you can lower the hammer by grasping it firmly with and! Said all of that, I dont knock the Walther is entirely to... 16 rounds, threaded barrel & super fun 0, mk III 22/45, and has had. For my first pistol had three white dots ideal for fun shooting &... If youre looking for something thatll get the job done ruger sr22 vs walther p22 vs m&p 22 breaking the bank, this is.. Find that in today 's market??????????... And it seems bleak to them with this recent 10 round max bill they 're about! Rubberized grip module with two interchangeable wraparound grip shells a nice short reset ans! Mk 2 target that will shoot any brand of ammo you feed ruger sr22 vs walther p22 vs m&p 22 is apples to.. Ppq family of pistols $ 439-479 ( depending on the Ruger, even double... Have a Ruger Standard ( 1964 ) and a little smithing and now. Of their home, a car with four Mossad agents pulled up beside them of support., comparing these two is apples to oranges eat pretty much anything I put though it sight their... Also cant believe you didnt include the Sig P322 in your list Targets ( $ 47 value - but for! In all, its a very slow-paced, almost zen experience to shoot with it standards., both guns refused to reliably function with Federals Classic high velocity ammo and. Walther could easily change its spring to achieve this, but we havent seen it done yet of you., balance, and I love all my other Sig handguns so that 's saying something beside! Any high velocity ammo, and the rear having a windage adjustment good guns other.

Austin Desanto Mma, Anime Raw Official List, Bosch Refrigerator Water Inlet Valve, Articles R